I was in an unfortunate, but ultimately very interesting interaction recently. I was accidentally included on an e-mail list notifying me that someone I don’t know has cancer which has now very likely turned terminal. This was either sent or cc’ed to a rather large number of people. And some of those people are, shall we say, ‘not friendly’ — apparently belonging to some twisted little isolated group of self-professing Christians. They instantly jumped on this news, declaring that the cancer victim brought it on himself. That it is his sin that caused this. Reasoned, tactful responses to these declarations unloaded the floodgates of Hades.
Everyone on that list has now been repeatedly broadcast this group’s views, which include several variations of “You’re all instruments of Satan.” And then, upon being soundly criticised by some (brave? foolish?) people, they have the audacity to say that they are being judged by their appearance and not the reality. And, of course, they question anybody’s right or authority to judge them at all. This while handing down their own astringent (not to mention unsolicited) judgements liberally.
It’s actually been pretty remarkable watching this unfold. Their style of “debate” is to preempt (pertinent) accusations by throwing out (baseless) ones of their own. It’s actually wickedly effective*. It goes like this: If I first call you a liar, and then make a baseless truth claim, your counter-accusation that I am a liar is infinitely weaker. Or if I tell you that you’re distorting scripture, and then do that myself, how could you make a sensible response? Or best yet, if I call you delusional, then how can you respond that really I am the delusional one? It would reduce you to 7 year-old see-saw name-calling. I’ve tied you up in knots and made you look like an idiot before I even let you speak.
In the initial case, with the horrifyingly spiteful responses to the cancer announcement, I was very tempted to say “Rather than being a judgement from the Lord, this cancer is actually His blessing: with friends/acquaintances like this, who wouldn’t be grateful for an ‘out’!?” But I didn’t say that. Because that’s not the kind of Christian I choose to be. But man, sometimes that choice is hard!
Instead I effectively just told them to “Shut up!”. But why bother? They never listen…
*that is to say, effective only at heading off rebuttal, and insulating you from needing to really engage the issues at hand. Not at all useful for actually convincing anybody of anything. Or, uh, making friends…